Rajiv Mehta | 21st November 2023 | 7 min read
In the complex realm of UK company law, one intriguing avenue to explore is the concept of alphabet shares. These unique shares provide companies with the flexibility to allocate varying rights among their shareholders, ranging from dividend entitlements to voting privileges and even directorial appointments. These shares are aptly named "alphabet shares" because they are literally labelled with alphabets, such as "A" shares, "B" shares, and more.
However, what sets alphabet shares apart is not just their distinct nomenclature; it's the immense potential they hold for tax efficiency and financial strategy. In this article, we will unravel the intricacies of alphabet shares, examining their application, tax implications, and the legal considerations that accompany them.
The Complexity of Alphabet Shares
Alphabet shares are a powerful tool that can be employed in tax planning and financial structuring. They empower companies to tailor shareholder rights, enabling the distribution of dividends at varying rates to different shareholders. The beauty of alphabet shares lies in their ability to confer unique rights, thereby allowing for flexible and strategic distribution of profits.
Navigating the Legal Landscape
To issue alphabet shares, companies must obtain approval from their existing shareholders, and the specific rights associated with these shares must be clearly defined within the company's articles of association. While alphabet shares provide a versatile framework for tailoring shareholder rights, they also introduce legal complexities that require a keen understanding of UK company law.
Tax Efficiency and HMRC Scrutiny
Alphabet shares offer a tax-efficient approach to profit distribution within a company. HMRC permits this practice as long as the shareholders are not closely related beyond their association with the company. However, when shareholders are family members, HMRC may scrutinize the legitimacy of such arrangements, making it essential to tread carefully.
Settlement Legislation and Precedents
The settlement legislation, outlined by HMRC in ITTOIA 2005, Part 5, Chapter 5, defines a settlement as any disposition, trust, covenant, agreement, arrangement, or transfer of assets. Its primary objective is to prevent individuals from gaining a tax advantage through the transfer of income from one family member to another, essentially creating a settlement. This legislation applies to spouses as well, ensuring that income transferred between spouses for tax reduction remains within the tax net.
A significant precedent that reinforces this perspective is the "Arctic Systems" case in the House of Lords. In this case, a transfer of income preference to dividends over salary was deemed impermissible, as it resembled a form of bounty and thus qualified as a settlement.
The Perfecting Solution with Alphabet Shares
Consider a scenario involving Tom, the owner and director of a company, A LTD, and his wife, Sandra, whose income fluctuates due to self-employment. To optimise tax benefits, Tom seeks to transfer a portion of his dividends to Sandra, taking advantage of her unused nil-rate and basic rate bands. However, transferring standard shares to Sandra would result in her having an identical dividend rate to Tom, which could pose a challenge when her variable income pushes her into higher tax rate bands, defeating the arrangement's purpose.
To address this challenge, companies like A LTD can issue alphabet shares, such as "A" ordinary shares. These alphabet shares possess the same rights as standard shares but introduce the flexibility to pay dividends at varying rates. This strategic approach allows dividends to be allocated to Sandra at different rates, aligning with her changing financial circumstances.
Navigating Potential Pitfalls
While alphabet shares offer a tax-efficient solution for dividend distribution among spouses, it's essential to be aware of the intricacies that could draw HMRC's attention. HMRC may scrutinize and potentially reject an arrangement if one class of shares is paid at a rate that exceeds the available profit, making it crucial to structure the dividend rate thoughtfully.
Seeking Expert Guidance with Financial Angels
For individuals and companies embarking on the journey of creating or restructuring their financial arrangements, expert guidance is indispensable.
Financial Angels, with its wealth of experience, specialises in helping clients navigate the nuances of UK company law and tax planning. We have a track record of assisting individuals and businesses in achieving legally compliant structures that are approved by HMRC.
We also collaborate with local accountants, providing support and guidance on similar setups through a white label facility. With Financial Angels, you can confidently master tax efficiency and financial strategy, ensuring your arrangements comply with regulations while maximizing tax benefits.
NOT ALL ACCOUNTANTS KNOW ABOUT ALPHABET SHARES ! THIS IS A SPECIALIST AREA !
If you would like to explore this in further detail, please contact us here